Loading...

South Africa LNG terminal faces fresh legal challenge over climate impact

South Africa LNG terminal faces fresh legal challenge over climate impact

A planned liquefied natural gas (LNG) import terminal in South Africa is facing a new legal challenge from environmental organisations, raising fresh questions about the climate impact of the country’s proposed expansion of gas infrastructure.

Three environmental groups have taken the project’s environmental authorisation to the KwaZulu-Natal High Court, seeking to have the approval and a subsequent appeal decision overturned. They argue that authorities failed to properly account for the project's greenhouse gas emissions, particularly those generated across the wider gas supply chain.

The legal action, filed on October 23, involves the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance, The Green Connection and groundWork. The organisations are represented by the Centre for Environmental Rights.

The dispute centres on the planned Richards Bay LNG terminal, which is expected to become South Africa’s first facility of its kind. The project, estimated to cost around $1 billion, is intended to import, store and distribute natural gas for electricity generation and industrial use.

The environmental groups argue that the assessment used to approve the project underestimated its overall climate impact by focusing too narrowly on emissions directly produced by the facility.

According to the project's climate assessment, its associated greenhouse gas emissions could reach approximately 627,000 tonnes annually. The organisations say nearly 99% of these emissions are indirect, arising from activities such as gas extraction, processing, liquefaction, shipping and the eventual use of the imported fuel.

They argue that these emissions should have been adequately considered before the environmental authorisation was granted.

The challenge targets the environmental approval issued on January 9, 2026, as well as an appeal decision dated April 25 that upheld the authorisation.

The terminal is part of South Africa’s broader efforts to diversify its energy supply and secure additional gas resources for power generation and industrial consumption.

The project is being developed by Zululand Energy Terminal, involving Vopak Terminal Durban and Transnet Pipelines. Its proposed infrastructure includes LNG import facilities, storage, regasification and distribution capacity.

However, the project has already faced uncertainty over its commercial viability and the development of related gas-fired power infrastructure.

In May 2026, Vopak postponed its final investment decision until 2028, citing the need for greater clarity on the proposed power plant and future gas demand. An initial agreement between Eskom and Zululand Energy Terminal was also signed in June to advance cooperation on gas and electricity development.

South Africa's energy transition under scrutiny

The case highlights a broader debate over the role of natural gas in South Africa’s energy transition.

Supporters of the project see imported gas as a potential source of additional energy supply for electricity generation and industry. Environmental organisations, however, warn that long-term investment in fossil fuel infrastructure could increase greenhouse gas emissions and create dependence on imported gas.

The legal challenge also raises a wider regulatory question: should environmental assessments for major gas infrastructure account only for emissions generated directly by a facility, or should they include emissions associated with the entire supply chain and the eventual combustion of the fuel?

The High Court's examination of the case could have implications for how South Africa assesses the climate impact of future fossil fuel projects.

For now, the legal action does not amount to a cancellation of the terminal. Its future will depend on the court's findings, the outcome of the environmental dispute and the project's ability to secure the investment needed to proceed.